Tin Solder vs Lead Solder: Koj Yuav Tsum Siv Dab Tsi?

Dec 31, 2025

Tso lus

Kev sib cav sib ceg ntawm cov hlau lead thiab cov hlau lead-dawb solder tau txuas ntxiv hauv kev tsim khoom siv hluav taws xob tau ze li ob xyoo lawm tam sim no, thiab hais ncaj ncees, nws tau muaj qhov nyuaj ntau dua li tsawg dua. Sn63/Pb37 eutectic solder- melting ntawm precisely 183℃-dominated kev lag luam rau qhov zoo ntawm ib puas xyoo ua ntej ib puag ncig cov kev cai yuam ib tug loj hloov. Niaj hnub no, SAC alloys (tin-silver-copper) tau dhau los ua lub neej ntawd hauv cov khoom siv hluav taws xob, tab sis cov hlau lead tsis kam tuag ntsiag to. Nkag siab txog qhov sib txawv ntawm cov hlau, kev tswj xyuas thaj chaw, thiab kev ua lag luam tawm tswv yim-offs tsis yog xaiv tau lawm; Nws yog ib qho tseem ceeb rau txhua tus neeg ua haujlwm nrog PCBs, txawm tias koj tab tom khiav cov kab ntau lawm lossis tsuas yog kho koj tus menyuam cov khoom ua si tawg.

Tin Solder vs Lead Solder

 

Chemistry Tsis muaj leej twg xav tham txog

 

Nov yog qhov hais txog cov hlau lead hauv solder uas feem ntau cov ntawv gloss tshaj: nws tsis nyob ntawd los ntawm kev sib tsoo. Lead poob lub melting point dramatically. Ntshiab tin melts ntawm 232 degree. Ntxiv 37% txhuas, thiab tam sim ntawd koj nyob ntawm 183 degree. Qhov ntawd tsis yog qhov sib txawv me me- uas yog qhov sib txawv ntawm cov khoom muaj sia nyob reflow thiab ib feem tuag.

Lub ntsiab lus eutectic tseem ceeb tshaj li tib neeg paub. Raws nraim 63/37 tin - txhuas piv, cov hlau hloov ntawm cov khoom mus rau cov kua tam sim ntawd. Tsis muaj pasty ntau yam. Tsis muaj qhov txawv txav hauv -nruab nrab ntawm lub xeev uas lub solder yog ib nrab- melted thiab ib nrab- khoom. Tsuas yog huv si, kwv yees tus cwj pwm.

SAC305 (96.5% tin, 3% nyiaj, 0.5% tooj liab)? Kub ntawm 217-220 degree. Thiab nws tsis muaj qhov tseeb eutectic-ib txwm muaj ib qho me me pasty ntau yam. Zoo li tsis tseem ceeb kom txog thaum koj tab tom cuam tshuam nrog cov khoom siv thermal-rhiab lossis sim rov ua haujlwm lub rooj tsavxwm yam tsis tau rhuav tshem qhov chaw nyob ib sab.

 

Vim Li Cas Lead -Dawb tshwm sim (Thiab yog vim li cas nws thiaj li nyuaj)

 

RoHS. Qhov ntawd yog cov lus teb luv luv.

Cov European Union Txoj Kev Txwv Cov Tshuaj Tiv Thaiv Cov Tshuaj Tiv Thaiv tau pib siv thaum Lub Xya Hli 1, 2006, thiab kev lag luam hluav taws xob tsis tau zoo ib yam. Qhov siab tshaj plaws ntawm cov hlau lead concentration: 1000 ppm (0.1% los ntawm qhov hnyav) hauv cov ntaub ntawv homogeneous. Nyiv muaj cov qauv zoo sib xws, txawm tias lawv tau nruj dua ntawm 500 ppm.

Tab sis ntawm no yog qhov uas nws tau nthuav. Cov lus qhia suav nrog kev zam. Siab- daim ntawv thov kev ntseeg siab- servers, network infrastructure, cov cuab yeej kho mob, aerospace, tub rog- tseem tuaj yeem siv leaded solder. Vim li cas? Vim tsis muaj leej twg xav tau pacemakers ua tsis tau vim tin whiskers. Tsis muaj leej twg xav tau dav hlau avionics tsim cov pob qij txha txias ntawm 30,000 ko taw.

Cov kev zam tseem txuas ntxiv mus ntxiv. Raws li tsis ntev los no xyoo 2025, EU tau txuas ntxiv kev zam rau cov hlau lead rau siab - kub solders (Ntau dua lossis sib npaug rau 85% cov ntsiab lus txhuas) txog xyoo 2027. Qhov laj thawj? "Kev hloov pauv tseem tsis tau ntseeg txaus." Tom qab yuav luag 20 xyoo. Cia qhov ntawd tso rau hauv.

 

Wetting. Nws yog Txhua Yam Txog Wetting.

 

Kuv tau saib cov kws paub txog kev tawm tsam nrog cov hlau lead -dawb solder rau xyoo, thiab feem ntau ntawm lawv cov kev ntxhov siab los ntawm ib qho khoom: ntub dej.

Leaded solder ntws. Nws kis thoob plaws tooj liab zoo li dej ntawm lub lauj kaub kub. Lub kaum sab xis yog qis, qhov nro ntawm qhov chaw ua haujlwm hauv koj qhov kev nyiam, thiab cov pob qij txha tsim yuav luag ib txwm. Koj tuaj yeem saib nws tshwm sim - lub solder rub nws tus kheej mus rau qhov kub, qhwv ib ncig ntawm cov hlau lead, puv vias.

Lead -dawb? Nws zaum ntawd. Ua siab tawv. Koj yuav tsum coax nws. Cov flux ua haujlwm hnyav dua, hlawv sai dua, thiab koj tau txais lub qhov rais nqaim ua ntej oxidation tua koj cov leeg. Lub kaum sab xis ntawm kev sib cuag yog siab dua, txhais tau hais tias cov khoom sib txuas tau nce ntau dua li nthuav tawm.

Qhov no tsis yog subjective. Lub sij hawm ntub dej rau SAC alloys ntawm qhov sib piv kub yog ntsuas ntev dua Sn63 / Pb37. Qee cov tuam ntxhab hais tias lawv cov qauv flux tau kaw qhov sib txawv. Lawv feem ntau yog dag, lossis tsawg kawg exaggerating.

 

Teeb meem kub tsis muaj leej twg daws tau

 

Peb caug - plaub degrees Celsius.

Qhov ntawd yog qhov sib txawv ntawm lub melting point ntawm eutectic tin - lead (183 degree) thiab SAC305 (217℃). Tsis zoo li ntau txog thaum koj xav txog dab tsi tshwm sim hauv qhov cub reflow.

Peak reflow kub rau cov khoom sib dhos: 225-235℃. Rau tsis muaj txhuas: 255-265 degree. Koj cov khoom tau ntub dej ntawm qhov kub siab dua ntev dua. Koj lub rooj tsavxwm yog warping ntau dua. Cov dej noo nyob rau hauv cov pob khoom yas muaj zog ntau dua rau vaporize thiab ua rau popcorning. Intermetallic compound kev loj hlob sai.

Thiab cov margins shrinks. Nrog rau cov hlau lead, koj muaj kwv yees li 40-50℃ntawm lub taub hau ntawm melting thiab puas. Nrog cov hmoov lead-dawb, lub qhov rais no nqaim mus rau 25-30 degree. Cov txheej txheem tswj ua qhov tseem ceeb. Koj qhov profile reflow zoo dua yog hu rau hauv zoo kawg nkaus, lossis koj nyob nraum scrapping boards.

Kuv tau pom cov kab ntau lawm hloov mus ua -dawb thiab muaj lawv cov nqi tsis raug peb zaug ib hmos. Tsis yog vim leej twg tau ua dab tsi tsis ncaj ncees lawm - lub qhov rais txheej txheem tsuas yog nruj dua.

 

Tin Whiskers: Dab Hauv Lub Tshuab

 
Tin Solder vs Lead Solder
 

Qhov no tsim nyog nws cov seem vim nws yog tiag tiag txaus ntshai.

Tin whiskers yog cov qauv crystalline uas spontaneously loj hlob los ntawm ntshiab tin nto. Lawv nyias nyias-qee zaum tsuas yog ib lub micron lossis ob txoj kab uas hla- thiab lawv tuaj yeem ncav cuag ob peb millimeters ntev. Lawv ua rau luv luv. Lawv tau nqis los ntawm satellites. Lawv tau ua tsis taus nuclear fais fab nroj tsuag tswj systems. Qhov no tsis yog hypothetical; muaj cov ntaub ntawv.

Cov hmoov txhuas tiv thaiv kev tsim cov nplaum nplaum. Txawm tias me me - tsawg li 3% - txo qis kev loj hlob ntawm whisker. Lub tshuab tsis nkag siab tag nrho, tab sis cov pov thawj empirical yog qhov nyuaj.

Lead- dawb solder muaj cov ntsiab lus tin ntau dua. Lead-dawb nto tiav (xws li cov tin plating) yog qhov tseem ceeb ua liaj ua teb uas tos kom tshwm sim. Kev lag luam teb? Conformal txheej. Ua tib zoo tswj kev ntxhov siab. Cia siab rau qhov zoo tshaj plaws.

Qee tus neeg tsim khoom ntxiv bismuth lossis lwm yam ntsiab lus txhawm rau txhawm rau lub ntsej muag. Cov txiaj ntsig tau sib xyaw. Qhov teeb meem tsis tau raug daws lawm- nws tau raug tswj hwm, hom.

 

Yuav ua li cas tshwm sim thaum koj nyob nraum Soldering

 

Cia kuv taug kev koj hla ib yam dab tsi ua tau.

Koj nyob ntawm koj lub rooj zaum nrog qhov kub thiab txias -tswj hlau. Cov khoom yuav tsum tau soldering.

Nrog 63/37 leaded solder:

Teem hlau rau 300-320 degree

Kov cov lus taw qhia rau kev sib koom ua ke, thov solder

Ob vib nas this, tej zaum peb

Ntxuav, ci, concave fillet

Ua tiav

Tib yam khoom, SAC305:

Hlau ntawm 350-380 degree

Ntau flux, tej zaum

Kov cov lus taw qhia rau kev sib koom ua ke, thov solder

Lub solder tsis ntws zoo

Ntxiv cua sov ntxiv

Peb mus rau tsib vib nas this tam sim no

Kev sib koom ua ke zoo li grainy, me ntsis npub (qhov no yog ib txwm rau cov hlau lead -dawb, tab sis nws tseem zoo li tsis ncaj ncees lawm rau leej twg tau kawm ntawm leaded)

Tej zaum tau txais, tej zaum rework

Lub tswv yim tactile txawv ib yam nkaus. Leaded solder muaj ib txoj kev txaus siab ntawm snapping los ntawm cov khoom mus rau cov kua. Lead- dawb yog mushier, tsawg dua txhais. Cov neeg txawj ntse kho. Pib tawm tsam.

 

Tin Solder vs Lead Solder

 

Khoom noj qab haus huv (vim ib tug neeg ib txwm nug)

 

Yog, txhuas yog tshuaj lom. Tsis muaj kev sib cav nyob ntawd.

Cov kab mob txhuas ntev ua rau muaj kev puas tsuaj rau lub paj hlwb, teeb meem raum, teeb meem kev loj hlob, kev loj hlob qeeb hauv cov menyuam yaus. Cov ntshav txhuas ntau dua 5 µg / dL raug suav hais tias nce siab los ntawm CDC cov qauv. Kev txwv kev ua haujlwm muaj nyob rau qhov laj thawj zoo.

Tab sis -thiab qhov no yog qhov tseem ceeb- txoj kev kis kab mob tseem ceeb tsis yog los ntawm kev sib cuag ntawm daim tawv nqaij. Nws yog ingestion. Ntxuav koj txhais tes tom qab soldering. Tsis txhob noj ntawm koj lub rooj zaum ua haujlwm. Kev tu cev yooj yim tshem tawm cov kev pheej hmoo feem ntau.

Cov pa taws uas koj pom thaum soldering? Qhov ntawd yog flux burning, tsis yog lead vapor. Lead lub boiling point yog 1749 degree. Koj cov hlau soldering tsis tau nyob ze. Qee cov hlau lead oxide tuaj yeem tsim thiab dhau los ua huab cua, tab sis cov ntsiab lus ntawm qhov kub ntawm qhov kub yog qis.

Qhov cua txaus txaus. Fume extractors pab. Tab sis qhov kev ntshai nyob ib ncig ntawm cov hlau lead tau raug me ntsis exaggerated rau hobbyist siv. Kev teeb tsa kev lag luam nrog qhov cuam tshuam tas li thiab kev tswj tsis txaus yog ib zaj dab neeg sib txawv.

Lead-dawb tsis muaj kev pheej hmoo- dawb ib yam. Rosin flux fumes ua rau ua pa rhiab heev rau qee tus neeg. Kev kub siab soldering txhais tau hais tias cov khoom lag luam flux decomposition ntau dua. Lwm qhov "kev nyab xeeb" muaj nws cov teeb meem.

 

Kev ntseeg tau: Qhov tseeb tsis yooj yim

 

Nov yog qee yam uas tus thawj coj-cov tshaj tawm dawb tsis tshaj tawm: qee qhov SAC alloys ua tau zoo dua cov tin- coj hauv qee qhov kev ntsuas kev ntseeg tau.

Thermal cycling? SAC305 feem ntau qhia tau hais tias qaug zog zoo dua. Ua haujlwm kub-? Lead-dawb tuav tau zoo dua. Creep kuj? Feem ntau superior hauv SAC alloys.

Tab sis.

Ua haujlwm poob siab? Leaded solder yeej. Cov pob qij txha yog ductile ntau, tsis tshua muaj nkig tawg. Kev vibration tsis kam? Kuj coj. Qhov chaw txias? Lead- dawb solder ua nkig hauv qab 0℃. Muaj txawm tias qhov tshwm sim hu ua "tin pest" qhov twg tin hloov mus rau qhov sib txawv crystalline qauv hauv qab 13 degree, txawm hais tias nws tsis tshua muaj nyob rau hauv alloys.

Cov lus teb tiag tiag yog qhov kev ntseeg siab nyob ntawm koj daim ntawv thov. Tsis yog universally "zoo dua." Leej twg qhia rau koj tsis yog muag ib yam dab tsi.

 

Kev them nqi

 

Tsis muaj leej twg tham txog qhov no txaus.

Cov nqi raw khoom rau SAC alloys khiav 2-3x siab dua tin-lead. Nyiaj tsis pheej yig. Rau kev ua haujlwm nthwv dej uas koj tab tom tuav lub lauj kaub ntawm molten solder, qhov no ntxiv nrawm.

 

Tab sis qhov ntawd tsuas yog cov khoom siv ncaj qha xwb. Factor hauv:

  • Siab dua - cov khoom ntsuas ntsuas (qee qhov tsis tuaj yeem ua cov hlau lead- dawb reflow kub)
  • Cov nqi hluav taws xob nce ntxiv rau - cov txheej txheem kub
  • Kev hloov pauv hloov ntau zaus (ua- tsis pub noj hlau sai dua)
  • Tighter txheej txheem tswj
  • Siab dua tus nqi rework

Ib txoj kev tshawb fawb kwv yees tag nrho cov nqi nce ntawm 5-15% rau kev hloov pauv tsis muaj hlau lead hauv cov kab SMT. Koj qhov mileage yuav txawv, tab sis nws yeej tsis pub dawb.

 

Tin Solder vs Lead Solder

 

Yog li Koj Yuav Tsum Siv Dab Tsi?

 

Nyob ntawm tag nrho cov ntsiab lus.

Lead -dawb:

Cov khoom muag hauv EU, Nyiv, lossis lwm yam RoHS- ua raws li kev lag luam

Cov khoom siv hluav taws xob

Txhua yam tsis muaj kev zam tshwj xeeb

Tej zaum coj:

Prototyping thiab hobby ua hauj lwm (yooj yim, pheej yig dua, ntau zam txim)

Aerospace, tub rog, kev kho mob (qhov twg muaj kev zam)

Siab - daim ntawv thov kev ntseeg siab uas ntev - kev coj cwj pwm tseem ceeb tshaj li kev ua raws cai

Rework chaw nres tsheb (kev sib xyaw ua ke ib sab, nws yooj yim dua)

Qhov nruab nrab pragmaticav: Ntau tus kws tshaj lij khaws ob qho tib si ntawm tes. Lead- pub dawb rau kev tsim khoom, ua rau rov ua dua tshiab thiab tsim qauv. Tsuas yog tsis txhob muab sib xyaw rau hauv tib qho kev sib koom ua ke - cov alloy uas tau tshwm sim muaj cov khoom tsis tuaj yeem thiab muaj ntau yam pasty.

 

Kev xav zaum kawg (Xaiv)

 

Kev lag luam tau hloov mus ua -dawb tsis yog vim nws yog technically superior- nws tsis yog, feem ntau ntawm kev hwm -tab sis vim hais tias ib puag ncig kev cai thov nws. Qhov ntawd zoo. Kev tiv thaiv ib puag ncig tseem ceeb. Tab sis cia peb tsis txhob ua txuj tias qhov kev hloov pauv tsis muaj mob lossis cov hlau lead -dawb solder yog lub hom phiaj "zoo dua" rau cov khoom siv hluav taws xob.

Nees nkaum xyoo nyob rau hauv, peb tseem tab tom cuam tshuam nrog tin whisker txaus ntshai, tseem siv kev zam rau cov ntawv thov tseem ceeb, tseem them nyiaj ntau dua rau cov txheej txheem uas nyuaj rau tswj. Cov tiam tom ntej ntawm engineers yuav tsis kov cov hlau lead, uas yog qhov zoo rau lawv. Lawv yuav tsis paub qhov lawv ploj lawm.

Rau txhua tus neeg: siv qhov ua tau zoo rau koj daim ntawv thov. Ua raws li cov cai uas lawv thov. Tsis txhob ntseeg leej twg qhia koj qhov no yooj yim. Nws yeej tsis yog.

 

Xa kev nug
Xa kev nug